Course 4 · Structures
Broken-wing butterflies and the side that keeps losing
Skipping one wing tears the symmetric tent. The package can show a credit or a debit from real sides only, and the wide side can keep losing until the far long strike. That credit is payment for the scar — not income. A missing far wing means the sketch is incomplete.
- Lesson
- 12 of 17
- Level
- Advanced
- {minutes} min read
- 10 minEST
- Prerequisites
- 2
Not a certificate. Progress stays on this device.
Before this: Long butterflies, Ratio spreads and backspreads
You'll be able to
- name what a skipped wing changes versus a symmetric fly
- name credit or debit only when body bid and wing asks exist
- point to the wide side that can keep losing
TL;DR
Skipping one wing tears the symmetric tent. The package can show a credit or a debit from real sides only, and the wide side can keep losing until the far long strike. That credit is payment for the scar — not income. A missing far wing means the sketch is incomplete.
Learn
A symmetric butterfly puts the long wings the same listed steps from the short body. A broken-wing butterfly keeps the short body and two long wings, then skips a listed strike on one side so the distances no longer match. The skip is the whole change. On the wide side the expiry sketch keeps falling as spot moves away from the body until the far long strike. If that far strike is not listed, the shape you drew is not the shape the book can hold — it is a ratio in disguise.
Name the package a credit only when the short body's bid (counted twice) is larger than the asks on both long wings, and only when those three sides are on the screen. Name it a debit when the wing asks are larger. Skipping a strike often pushes one wing farther from spot, where the ask is smaller, so a debit fly can print as a credit once broken. That credit is not income. It is payment for wearing the wide side. If any side is blank, you have neither a credit nor a debit — you have an incomplete chain. Never a fake mid.
Between the body and the far long strike the short pair dominates. Each step toward that far strike adds loss until the far long option offsets the shorts in count. The eventual flat past the far strike is a property of a complete package at settlement — not of the path, and not of a book whose far strike never traded. Margin can raise the short body before that flat arrives. A gap can cross the skipped rungs in one move. Path dependence and split legs under venue rules (UNVERIFIED) can leave an uncovered stub.
On the strategy desk, sketch three strikes of one type and one expiry, count listed steps on each side, and write which side is wider. Then switch to the chain and record bid and ask for each of the three strikes separately. If the far wing is missing, stop and label the sketch incomplete. Missing quotes stay missing. Skew is context for why the far wing's ask is rich or cheap relative to the body — not a fill, and not a reason to ignore a missing bid.
Worked example · EXAMPLE
Call fly with body at 100k, near wing 95k (1 step), far wing 115k (skipping 110k). Listed steps: narrow side 1, wide side 3 (EXAMPLE).
Quoted sides (EXAMPLE): - Body 100k call bid ×2: 2 × 3,800 = 7,600 - Near wing 95k ask: 5,200 - Far wing 115k ask: 900 - Net on those sides: 7,600 − 5,200 − 900 = credit 1,500 - Wide side that can keep losing: between 100k and 115k. - If 115k has no bid and no ask, the package is incomplete — do not name a credit.
| Leg | Strike | Side used | Premium (EXAMPLE) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Short 2× body | 100,000 | bid ×2 | 7,600 |
| Long near wing | 95,000 | ask | 5,200 |
| Long far wing | 115,000 | ask | 900 |
| Net | — | credit if sides exist | 1,500 |
Try it
Lay three strikes and a skip on the strategy desk. Count listed steps, name the wide side, then confirm all three strikes are two-sided on the chain.
Common mistakes
- Calling the credit income. - Filling a missing far wing from a model or a neighbour expiry. - Counting dollar distance instead of listed steps on an uneven ladder. - Mixing two expiries and calling the result a broken wing.
In your market
Crypto: European cash settlement removes early exercise, but a margin close-out can still split the package (UNVERIFIED).
Equities: American short body legs add early-assignment risk on the short pair.
Index: European cash settlement removes early exercise; the wide side and missing-wing rule still apply.
Futures options: SPAN-style margin on the short body can jump as spot approaches it (UNVERIFIED).
FX: premium units and strike grids still require listed wings before you name a credit.
Quiz
Not financial advice. This lesson is education only. It does not recommend any trade or say any approach will make money. Every number tagged EXAMPLE is made up to show the arithmetic; none of it is live data. MODEL numbers come from Black-76 with the stated inputs and will differ from any venue's quotes. Venue specs, settlement times, margin and fees are UNVERIFIED: check each venue yourself. Options can lose all the premium paid, and short options can lose far more than the premium collected. Size every position to its max loss.
Try it
Strategy desk →Quiz
1. What makes a butterfly "broken wing"?
Unequal listed steps because one strike is skipped on one side.
2. EXAMPLE net on the quoted sides?
Credit 1,500 (EXAMPLE).
3. Which side can keep losing in the EXAMPLE?
Between the 100k body and the 115k far wing.
4. When is a credit not knowable?
When any of the body bid or wing asks is absent.
5. Is the credit income?
No — it is payment for wearing the wide side.
Key terms
Educational content only — not financial advice. Product rules vary by venue; verify on the exchange. OptionsMatch labels Snapshot / Partial / Last good on Match, and LIVE, Partial data, or EXAMPLE on Terminal desks.