Course 9 · Trader Process
Journaling
A trade journal is a fixed set of fields you fill before entry and after exit. Its job is honesty: the plan, the fill, the outcome, and whether you followed yourself. Record results in R, where 1R is the planned max loss, so trades of different size compare fairly. A journal does not improve results by itself; it gives you something you can review without rewriting history.
- Lesson
- 1 of 6
- Level
- Intermediate
- {minutes} min read
- 6 minEST
- Prerequisites
- none
Not a certificate. Progress stays on this device.
You'll be able to
- set up a trade journal with fixed before and after fields
- record a trade in R (multiples of planned max loss)
- separate plan, fill and outcome
TL;DR
A trade journal is a fixed set of fields you fill before entry and after exit. Its job is honesty: the plan, the fill, the outcome, and whether you followed yourself. Record results in R, where 1R is the planned max loss, so trades of different size compare fairly. A journal does not improve results by itself; it gives you something you can review without rewriting history.
Learn
Process starts on paper, not on the fill. A journal is the place where you lock the view, the structure, the size and the exits *before* the market can rewrite them. If you wait until after the result, memory edits the story: winners get clever reasons, losers get excuses. Fixed fields stop that edit.
Before entry, fill: date and time (with zone), view (direction, how far, by when), structure and legs, limit price, max loss, max gain, break-even, size and 1R in money, exits (target, loss, time), and why now. The "why now" line is the one people skip, then invent later. Write it while the trade is still a choice.
After exit, fill: fill prices, exit reason (target, loss, time, view changed, other), P/L in money and in R, fees, did I follow the plan (yes/no and where not), and one sentence on what you'd do the same or differently. When a trade lost money, name the real reason in plain language: wrong direction, wrong vol, wrong expiry, fees, or process (for example no written loss exit). If you cannot name it, you will repeat it.
R: R = P/L ÷ planned max loss. A trade that loses its full planned max loss is −1R. Money alone hides size: a +200 on a 500 risk and a +200 on a 5,000 risk look the same in currency and very different in R. Journaling in R is how later reviews stay comparable.
Management notes belong in the same book. If you change a position mid-trade — close, add a wing, roll, convert a short into a spread — treat that as a new decision with remaining max loss written down. Hope ("it will come back") is not a field. Remaining risk is.
Worked example · EXAMPLE
Bull call 100k/110k, 2 contracts of 0.1 BTC, filled at 2,500, fees ignored (EXAMPLE).
- Planned max loss: 2,500 × 0.1 × 2 = 500 → 1R = 500. - Exit: closed when the spread was worth 3,500 (time exit, 7 days left). - P/L: (3,500 − 2,500) × 0.1 × 2 = +200. - In R: 200 ÷ 500 = +0.4R. - Followed plan: yes (time exit as written).
| Field | Entry |
|---|---|
| View | Up, not past 110k, 30 days |
| Structure | +100k C / −110k C |
| 1R | 500 |
| Exit reason | Time |
| Result | +200 / +0.4R |
| Plan followed | Yes |
Try it
Rebuild the EXAMPLE bull call in the [strategy desk](/t/BTC/strategy), read max loss off the structure, then write a full before/after journal line using 1R = that max loss. Do not wait for a live fill to practise the fields.
Common mistakes
- Writing the "why" after the result is known. - Recording money only, so a big trade's result drowns out small ones. - Skipping journal entries for losing trades (those are the ones that teach). - Leaving out fees, then wondering why live P/L disagrees with the notebook. - Logging a management change without updating remaining max loss.
In your market
Crypto: note coin vs USDC settlement and the venue's expiry clock in your zone (UNVERIFIED per venue); weekends still count.
Equities: log earnings and ex-dividend dates in the before fields when they sit inside your expiry.
Index: AM vs PM settlement changes the "time" exit; write which print you mean.
Futures options: the underlying is a future; journal the futures expiry as well as the option expiry.
FX: OTC tickets and listed contracts use different clocks; put the source next to the timestamp.
Quiz
Not financial advice. This lesson is education only. It does not recommend any trade or say any approach will make money. Every number tagged EXAMPLE is made up to show the arithmetic; none of it is live data. Venue specs, settlement times, margin and fees are UNVERIFIED: check each venue yourself. Options can lose all the premium paid, and short options can lose far more than the premium collected. Size every position to its max loss.
Try it
OptionsMatch strategy desk →Quiz
1. What is 1R?
The planned max loss for that trade.
2. P/L +200 with 1R = 500 (EXAMPLE). Result in R?
+0.4R.
3. A trade loses its full planned max loss. In R?
−1R.
4. Name two "before" fields.
Any two of: view, structure, max loss, exits, size, limit price, why now.
5. Why fill the "why now" field before entry?
So hindsight cannot rewrite it after the result is known.
Key terms
Educational content only — not financial advice. Product rules vary by venue; verify on the exchange. OptionsMatch labels Snapshot / Partial / Last good on Match, and LIVE, Partial data, or EXAMPLE on Terminal desks.