Course 9 · Trader Process
Post-trade review
A review asks two separate questions: was the decision sound with what you knew, and did you follow your plan? The outcome is a third, noisier fact. Review in batches, in R, and treat a handful of trades as too few to prove anything. The goal is to find process errors you can fix, not to explain each result.
- Lesson
- 2 of 6
- Level
- Intermediate
- {minutes} min read
- 6 minEST
- Prerequisites
- 1
Not a certificate. Progress stays on this device.
Before this: Journaling
You'll be able to
- separate decision quality from outcome
- review a batch of trades in R
- avoid conclusions from small samples
TL;DR
A review asks two separate questions: was the decision sound with what you knew, and did you follow your plan? The outcome is a third, noisier fact. Review in batches, in R, and treat a handful of trades as too few to prove anything. The goal is to find process errors you can fix, not to explain each result.
Learn
Outcome is loud. Process is quiet. A review that only asks "did I make money?" trains you to keep broken habits that happened to pay and to scrap sound ones that happened to lose. Separate the questions: with the information I had, was the plan coherent? Did I follow it? What did the market do? Those are three columns, not one verdict.
Process vs outcome grid. Followed plan + good outcome: fine; do not over-credit it. Followed plan + bad outcome: fine; do not over-blame it. Broke plan + bad outcome: clear lesson. Broke plan + good outcome: the dangerous box — it rewards the wrong habit and is easy to defend because the money looked kind.
| Good outcome | Bad outcome | |
|---|---|---|
| Followed plan | Fine; do not over-credit it | Fine; do not over-blame it |
| Broke plan | Dangerous: teaches the wrong habit | Clear lesson |
Batch review: every N trades (your choice), total and average R, count of plan breaks, and the most common exit reason. Also tally why losers lost: direction, vol, expiry, fees, or process. Patterns show up in counts, not in one dramatic story.
Sample size: a few trades can swing on chance alone. Treat early numbers as notes, not findings. Changing the method after three trades is how noise becomes a new rule. The journal from Lesson 1 feeds this review; without R and plan-followed flags, the grid has nowhere to sit.
Worked example · EXAMPLE
Four journal entries, 1R = 500 each (EXAMPLE):
| Trade | Result (R) | Plan followed? |
|---|---|---|
| A | +0.4 | Yes |
| B | −1.0 | Yes |
| C | −0.5 | No (moved loss exit) |
| D | +1.2 | No (no time exit) |
- Total: 0.4 − 1.0 − 0.5 + 1.2 = +0.1R (= +50 in money). - Average: 0.1 ÷ 4 = +0.025R. - Plan breaks: 2 of 4. Reading it: D had the largest gain but broke the plan — the dangerous box. Four trades say almost nothing about the method; they do show a habit (two plan breaks) worth fixing. C's break was a moved loss exit; that is a process tag, not a "market was unfair" story.
Try it
Place your last five journal entries in the grid. For any structure you are still unsure about, open it again on the [strategy desk](/t/BTC/strategy) and re-read max loss before you argue with the outcome.
Common mistakes
- Judging a decision by its outcome alone. - Reviewing only losses (winners that broke the plan teach the dangerous box). - Changing the method after three trades. - Reviewing in money, so size changes hide the pattern. - Explaining every result instead of counting process breaks.
In your market
Crypto: 24/7 tape makes "end of day" a choice; pick a review clock and stick to it.
Equities: separate overnight gap outcomes from daytime process breaks in the journal tags.
Index: cash settlement can make a "held to expiry" result look tidy while the process was still a plan break.
Futures options: roll decisions across futures months need their own plan-followed flag.
FX: session opens differ by pair; batch reviews should note which session the fills came from.
Quiz
Not financial advice. This lesson is education only. It does not recommend any trade or say any approach will make money. Every number tagged EXAMPLE is made up to show the arithmetic; none of it is live data. Venue specs, settlement times, margin and fees are UNVERIFIED: check each venue yourself. Options can lose all the premium paid, and short options can lose far more than the premium collected. Size every position to its max loss.
Try it
OptionsMatch strategy desk →Quiz
1. Total R of A–D in the EXAMPLE batch?
+0.1R.
2. Average R over those four trades?
+0.025R.
3. Which box is called dangerous, and why?
Broke plan with a good outcome; it rewards the wrong habit.
4. Is +0.025R over four trades evidence the method works?
No; the sample is far too small.
5. Why review in R?
So trades of different size compare fairly.
Key terms
Educational content only — not financial advice. Product rules vary by venue; verify on the exchange. OptionsMatch labels Snapshot / Partial / Last good on Match, and LIVE, Partial data, or EXAMPLE on Terminal desks.